Here’s a bold statement: Peacemaker Season 2, for all its brilliance, stumbles on one of its most intriguing subplots—and it’s a miss that’s hard to ignore. But here’s where it gets controversial: while the season masterfully weaves character development across dimensions, from Nazi-ruled worlds to candy imp-infested realms, it inexplicably drops the ball on Eagly’s Prime Eagle arc. Yes, the eagle with a penchant for luncheon meat and car rides turns out to be a mythical powerhouse—a revelation that could’ve reshaped the entire narrative. So, why did the show abandon this thread after just one episode? Let’s dive in.
James Gunn’s Peacemaker is a masterclass in balancing chaos with character growth. From Judomaster (Nhut Le) and Adebayo (Danielle Brooks) bonding over their shared struggles on Earth-X to Vigilante (Freddie Stroma) and Langston Fleury (Tim Meadows) discovering their love for animal trivia, the show uses its multiverse madness to deepen connections. And this is the part most people miss: even the absurdity serves a purpose—until it doesn’t. Take Eagly’s Prime Eagle reveal in Season 2, Episode 6 (Ignorance is Chris). After episodes of Red St. Wild (Michael Rooker) obsessively hunting Eagly, convinced he’s the leader of all eagles, the show confirms it—only to sideline the entire storyline in the next episode. Why?
The answer lies in how Eagly’s powers function within the narrative. As the Prime Eagle, Eagly could summon flaming auras and eagle armies, but these abilities work best as a low-stakes joke. The audience knows Eagly’s secret, but Peacemaker (John Cena) and the 11th Street Kids remain blissfully unaware. This contrast elevates Eagly’s character, making his mundane antics—like pecking at fridges or riding in cars—hilariously ironic. Here’s the controversial take: Maybe some mysteries are better left unsolved. Fully exploring Eagly’s powers might’ve distracted from the season’s larger themes of self-discovery and teamwork.
Still, it’s hard not to wonder: What if Eagly’s arc had been fleshed out further? Could it have added depth or derailed the story? Red St. Wild’s obsession and eventual death gave the subplot weight, but without him, there’s no natural direction for it to go. So, here’s the question for you: Did Peacemaker make the right call by shelving Eagly’s Prime Eagle status, or did it miss an opportunity to expand its universe? Let’s debate in the comments—because sometimes, the most interesting stories are the ones left untold. Peacemaker Season 2 is now streaming on Max, so you can judge for yourself.
